I haven't seen Lady Gaga in American Horror Story, only in the two movies. She seems to be very selective when it comes to taking roles which I think is a good thing. So far I would describe myself as "neutral" when it comes to her. I don't mind when she's cast. But it doesn't make me want to see a film more.

Phoenix's performance in the first movie is impressive and intense. But also scary. And I'm not sure how often I want to see him play that role. But of course I will watch the movie eventually one way or another.